Blake Lively Vs. Scarlett Johansson: Compare Their Engagement Rings!

Ryan Reynolds and Blake Lively in Charleston, SC on September 10, 2012; Scarlett Johansson on May 5, 2008 in New York City. Andrew H. Walker/Getty Images (Johannson)

Ryan Reynolds has excellent taste in engagement rings!

The 35-year-old actor tied the knot with actress Blake Lively, 25, in a private Southern wedding on Sept. 9 at Boone Hall Plantation. A day after the romantic ceremony, the Gossip Girl actress was photographed kissing her husband and showing off her gorgeous engagement ring in Charleston, South Carolina.

"Ryan chose Lorraine Schwartz to help him find a flawless, light pink oval diamond," a spokesperson for the jeweler told Us Weekly. "They worked together to design a custom setting in rose gold and pave diamonds with a nod to deco."

This is the second marriage for The Change-Up actor, who married actress Scarlett Johansson, 27, in Sept. 2008 before filing for divorce in Dec. 2010.

For Johansson's ring, Reynolds chose a traditional round-cut diamond set in a yellow gold band. A rep for designer Chris Capri Jewelry told E! News the ring would have cost approximately between $100,000 and $300,000, depending on the clarity.

In December 2011, Johansson told Cosmopolitan magazine that she doesn't regret her two-year marriage to Reynolds. "I'm a big believer that when something feels right, you should do it," she said. "I'm a big believer in instinct. Getting married was the right thing to do because it was natural. It grew out of a romance and love and a desire to have a future with somebody, and I was very fortunate that I married somebody who turned out to be the person I thought he would be." 

Since splitting from Reynolds, Johansson had a five-month romance with actor Sean Penn, 52. She has now been dating NYC-based ad executive Nate Naylor for nearly a year.

Sign up now for the Us Weekly newsletter to get breaking celebrity news, hot pics and more delivered straight to your inbox!

Want stories like these delivered straight to your phone? Download the Us Weekly iPhone app now!