Carrie Underwood recently gushed "I Love You" to hockey player Mike Fisher on the liner notes to her new album, Play On. But when she first heard about the Ottawa Senator hockey player, 29, through one of her band members, she had her doubts.
"He was like, 'I have this guy for you,'" Underwood, 26, says on The Ellen DeGeneres Show Wednesday (check your local listings). "I was like, 'Oh, that's great! What does he do?'"
Told he played hockey, she says she then asked, "Does he have his own teeth?"
"'No,'" she says her band member replied. "'But he's got his really good dentist!'"
When she was told he also lived in Canada, Underwood says it was another thumbs down.
"I love Canada," she says, "but that is a long distance relationship."
Today – after nearly a year together – she says, "We see each other more than people think we see each other. We don't go out like publicly. We just do our thing."
Underwood – who previously dated Tony Romo and Chace Crawford – says Fisher is "the longest relationship I've had. I joke and say my dogs are the longest relationship ever."
But, as she recently stated on her fan site, they have no plans to live together.
"Call me old fashion," she says. "The next guy I move in with will be my hubby. Who ever that is. I'm not saying it's going to be him."
DeGeneres then tells Underwood that she predicts they will wed and start a family.
"Apparently," Underwood says. "I don't know."
Sign up now for the Us Weekly newsletter to get breaking celebrity news, hot pics and more delivered straight to your inbox!