The "Body Say" singer, 24, kept her identity a secret by wearing a hat and sunglasses during the gag, which went down in Denver, Colorado. She took unsuspecting customers for a spin, and dropped several hints about who she really was with each turn.
"It's a job, like, cool for the summer," Lovato said to one woman, referring to her 2015 hit song.
With another passenger, she teased her tour with longtime pal Nick Jonas. "I actually really want to be a singer somebody. I've actually been traveling the country with my ex-boyfriend's brother because he sings too. We really want to get our names out there. Open mic nights and anything we can do," she said. (Reminder: Lovato and Joe Jonas briefly dated in 2010.)
The rider didn't catch on — and neither did the next.
"What type of music do you listen to? I really love Nick Jonas," Lovato said during another drive.
"I think he's here tomorrow night with Demi," the customer replied.
Lovato quipped: "Demi who?"
The "Stone Cold" singer couldn't stop laughing behind the driver's seat. She belted out tunes from her former Disney show Camp Rock and even joked about Nick and Joe Jonas' discarded purity rings. But along the way, she did have to face brutal honesty. At one point, a woman agreed that her pal Selena Gomez definitely has a better voice than her.
"I just insulted the hell out of you!" the woman said to Lovato after she realized who she really was. "I'm so sorry!"
Watch the funny Lyft drive in the video above!
Sign up now for the Us Weekly newsletter to get breaking celebrity news, hot pics and more delivered straight to your inbox!