Love Is Blind host Nick Lachey might have dropped a major clue about John Shannon and Sarah Williams’ divorce in a brief teaser for the upcoming season 11 reunion.
“I’ll ask you point blank, did you cheat on your wife?” Nick, 52, said in a trailer for the season 11 tell-all, which was featured at the very end of the Wednesday, November 4, finale.
While the cameras cut before anyone could answer, John, 33, and Sarah, 34, were the only season 11 couple to tie the knot this season. (Love Is Blind season 11, which was filmed in Boston, was filmed in 2025 and began airing on Netflix this fall.)
“Whatever you are trying to hide on this stage, it will come out,” Nick, who cohosts the dating experiment with wife Vanessa Lachey, later added in the teaser footage. (It’s presently unclear who Nick was addressing with his remark.)
Hours after the finale dropped on Netflix, news broke that Sarah had reportedly filed for divorce back in June after allegedly separating from John earlier this year. Neither Sarah nor John have publicly addressed their separation.
Sarah and John got engaged sight unseen in the Love Is Blind pods after navigating difficult conversations about their varying beliefs.
“It was a very long conversation,” Sarah exclusively told Us in October. “[Our] opinions weren’t that differing. I understand why people are saying that when I watch it back, as well.”
She continued, “I think we, like, actually really, like, came together, and I almost just had met in the middle. But I actually don’t even think it was meeting in the middle. … I think that I almost wish everyone could have seen the full conversation, because I think it was a wonderful conversation. I appreciated the conversation, and that’s why we kept moving forward.”
Navigating past any conflicts, John and Sarah each easily said “yes” on their wedding day.
“We did it, we’re married! Love is blind,” John said in a joint confessional with Sarah. “Sure, I might have been happyish by myself, but not even close to how happy I could be with the right person.”
John further gushed that Sarah makes him a “better person” and that he loves her, adding, “I’m excited for a life with you.”
John and Sarah are expected to reveal what happened after their wedding day during the season 11 reunion, which airs on Netflix Sunday, November 8, at 9 p.m. ET.
