Pia Toscano's early American Idol exit Thursday may have been a shocker, but Idol devotees know full well that the 22-year-old is hardly the first contestant to be booted too soon.
From Jennifer Hudson — whose season 3 exit left some fans blaming a power outage in her Chicago hometown — to Chris Daughtry falling victim to voter apathy in season 5, UsMagazine.com has rounded up the biggest Idol shockers of all time.
For her part, Toscano seems at peace with having to say goodbye.
"You don't know for sure why things happen, but you know, it did!" Toscano told reporters during a Friday conference call. "It was my time to go on the show and I'm excited to see what my future holds."
Tell Us: Which contestant's elimination was Idol's most shocking ever?
Sign up now for the Us Weekly newsletter to get breaking celebrity news, hot pics and more delivered straight to your inbox!