Us Poll: Does Jessica Simpson Look Better Today or a Year Ago?

See Results »
2009
77% 27391
2010
23% 8201
Celebrity Style August 31, 2010 AT 3:44PM
4/11/09, 8/29/10

4/11/09, 8/29/10

Credit: NATIONAL PHOTO GROUP; X17online.com

Repeat offender!

Jessica Simpson gave fans fashion deja vu when she wore an orange, blossom-covered shirt-dress to a Hawaiian party in Hancock, Park, Calif. on Sunday with main squeeze Eric Johnson (see photo, right).

PHOTOS: Jessica's many men

Simpson, now 30, wore the same leg-flashing number back in April 2009 while dining at Beso restaurant in Hollywood (see photo, left).

Tell Us: Does Jess look better then or now in the same outfit?

Tell Us What You Think

71
Comment by signing in with or creating your Facebook account by clicking below.
  • September 09, 2010 - 11:47am Dawn Babinetz

    She's still pretty and famous and you all can rank on her all you want... you'll never meet her caliber. As for wearing the same thing twice, what's the big deal? I'm sure she doesn't wear something once and throw it out... wake up people..... FURTHERMORE, she is not fat. Kirstie Alley, Snookie and Oprah are fat. Open your eyes and get a reality check. And, quit your hating, it makes you ugly inside...

  • September 01, 2010 - 6:49pm Phyllis Newman

    Hey, Imitalian, you're astupid. Fat? Seriously folks, you need help if you think she is fat. The girls making snarky comments about Jessica's weight are probably sitting there in their size 2 jeans looking like a 10 year old boy. A woman's natural body should have curves.

  • September 01, 2010 - 2:45pm Soriah Peble

    You know what’s even better than this? “Minute to Win It” on NBC. That game show has so much drama and excitement going on it makes Pairs Hilton look like afternoon stroll in the park! I’m serious…Check it out! facebook/minutetowinit

  • September 01, 2010 - 1:21pm Yourflin Ones

    Weight has NOTHING whatsoever to do with "curves". 1) a female doesnt need curves to be sexy at all. Frankly. My fiancee is a former gymnast and it was very exciting to watch her in the gym around all those sexy gymnast ladies who arent known for curves but are extremely sexy and fit. The fittest of all females on earth besides circus performers . 2) A thin woman can have curves. Curves are "hour glass" figure and "large breasts". My fiancee is thin but has an hourglass shape. Not ironing board. 4) a heavier female can have the curves of an ironing board or brickhouse. Having weight doesnt automatically mean you have curves. 5) A thin woman can have large curvy breasts and a curvy woman can have small ones (are small breasts "curvy"? thats debatable) . 6) A thin woman can be a "real woman". When heavier women say "I'm curvy. I'm a real woman and thin women arent real women. They are sticks" it sounds like "I'm a nazi. I'm a real human and jews arent real humans". Thats creepy. Superiority complex. 7?) as for jessica, she isnt all that sexy but she does have curves where they matter (in her chest). I like her before better. (wmwaf)

  • September 01, 2010 - 10:08am Cris

    Just because shes curvy doesnt mean shes fat!!!! I have to agree with Mimi sometimes she doesnt wear the most flattering clothes that suit her!!!!

  • September 01, 2010 - 9:59am nikki

    Its about being healthy people! And overall, right now Jessica does not look healthy at all.!!

  • September 01, 2010 - 9:21am Ash456

    TO all of those who are sitting here critiquing Jessica Simpson's weight-- I would like to see a picture of you on this site to let the world critique you! What is our society coming to that women are sitting here telling a beautiful woman what is wrong with her? I doubt all of you are 120 pounds and 5'10.

  • September 01, 2010 - 9:08am two cents

    I think age and unhappiness and disappointment is catching up with her and it shows. A women can have curves and look healthy -- look at Kim Kardashian -- but Jessica looked out of shape and like she has given up. She seems very unhappy despite the fact that she keeps harping about being in a good place. I get a terrible vibe from this new guy -- she has a horrible track record with men with the exception of Nick.

  • September 01, 2010 - 8:41am haha

    Lois, Why do you go yell at someone who is 300-400 lbs instead of someone who is not obese.

  • September 01, 2010 - 8:40am haha

    I agree with Mimi. I dont think shes as big as the pictures look. I just think the majority of her outfits are NOT flattering. Plus, its tought going from a size 00 to becoming fuller. She could be a size 4, but look bigger bc she was a 00. I think shes beautiful and as long as shes happy, she should be content.

  • September 01, 2010 - 5:38am .b

    people should just leave jess alone, she's human just like everyone else!

  • September 01, 2010 - 5:01am Mimi

    I first of all state that i think Jessica is a beautiful lady. As she has a fuller figure (which i am not slating as i am a fuller figure lady myself) some of her outfits are just not as flattering. I must state that im not dissin her figure as i believe she is just as beautiful smaller as she is a bit bigger!!!!

  • September 01, 2010 - 4:46am Nicki

    everything is CHUNKY this year!

  • September 01, 2010 - 4:30am .

    she looks horrible, seriously.

  • September 01, 2010 - 2:01am tj

    She looks GREAT, what a real woman should look like and not no "I'm on a celebrity diet" to appease my fans type figure.

  • September 01, 2010 - 1:57am Lois

    Jessica, I love you, but PLEASE LOSE SOME WEIGHT!!!

  • September 01, 2010 - 12:34am roXy

    hahah....fatty!

  • September 01, 2010 - 12:17am imitalian

    she is lazy and letting herself go. she got no responsibilities so why she getting all fat? go excerice you fat cow, its not like you got to work everyday nine to five or maintain a household or kids???

  • September 01, 2010 - 12:17am MARIA

    disgusting poll!! leave her alone!!!. Then media is "worried" about anorexic actresses. LEAVE. HER. ALONE.

  • August 31, 2010 - 11:58pm MG

    I think she looks amazing. She has a good heart and stands up for women of all sizes.

ADVERTISEMENT