Did the Super Bowl champ take home another win? Peyton Manning and Magic Johnson went head-to-head for a hilarious round of Russian Egg Roulette on Wednesday, February 10. The athletes were, um, egged on to play by Jimmy Fallon during The Tonight Show.

The Denver Broncos quarterback, 39, and Johnson, 56, wore matching hoodies over their suits for the messy match. The competition was filled with loud cackles, smack talk and lots and lots of yolk.

That was especially the case in the first round. Manning and the former NBA player both cracked raw eggs on their head to start the game.

"What is going on?" Fallon said. "In the history of this game, that has never happened. Thanks for coming here!"

Manning, however, joked that maybe dropping by was a bad idea. After all, he was on such a high after beating the Carolina Panthers 24 to 10 on Sunday, February 7.

"I won the Super Bowl!" he exclaimed. "This should not be happening."

To find out who won Egg Roulette, watch the funny video above!

Can't get enough of Us? Sign up now for the Us Weekly newsletter packed with the latest celeb news, hot pics and more!