Which of Idol's Top 12 Guys Wowed the Most?

See Results »
Scotty McCreery
30% 661
Jacob Lusk
19% 418
James Durbin
22% 496
Casey Abrams
29% 634
Entertainment Mar. 2, 2011 AT 10:25AM
Which of Idol's Top 12 Guys Wowed the Most? Credit: Michael Becker/FOX (4)

It's officially game on for American Idol's season 10!

The Top 12 male contestants hit the stage for the first time Tuesday, and while some faltered, there were a handful of guys that really stood out to Us.

PHOTOS: Meet Idol's Top 24!

Among them? Milwaukee singer Scotty McCreery, who belted out John Michael Montgomery's "Letters From Home" and earned raves from the judges. "You're born to sing country music," judge Jennifer Lopez told McCreery.

Steven Tyler deemed Jacob Lusk's appearance on the Idol stage "divine intervention" and Lopez drew a comparison between Lusk and the late Luther Vandross after Lusk's syrupy rendition of "A House is Not a Home." "This is what's so exciting about this show. [Luther]'s gone, but now we have you," she said.

VIDEO: See the Idol audition that made Jennifer cry

Tyler was so taken by James Durbin's version of Judas Priest's "You've Got Another Thing Comin'," that the judge dropped the F-bomb. "That was f--king crazy good!" he enthused.

And when Casey Abrams hit the stage, the rocker continued to dole out high praise. "You are in your mind good and out of your mind unreal," Tyler said. Abrams -- who was reportedly taken to the hospital for abdominal pain last week -- seemed in top form as he sang "I Put a Spell on You."

PHOTOS: Hilarious old pics of Steven and his fellow Idol judges

As the Top 12 girls prepare to hit the Idol stage tonight, tell Us which of these male semifinalists got your vote. If we missed your favorite, tell Us who you're rooting for in the comments section.

By Allison Corneau for UsMagazine.com. For more Channel Surfing, click here.

comments powered by Disqus