His lips are sealed! Ryan Reynolds and Blake Lively have chosen not to reveal the name of their 1-month-old baby daughter, but that didn't stop David Letterman from trying to guess it when the Mississippi Grind actor stopped by the Late Show on Wednesday, Feb. 4.
"We definitely [have a name]," Reynolds, 38, assured the host. Joking, he added, "I threw out the idea of just never naming the kid to be totally original, but we have a name. I just don't want to say it in, like, a media context. I tell everyone who I meet, so it'll come out."
Letterman proceeded to grill the first-time father for clues, asking whether it's a family name (it is), Lively's mother's name (it's not), and/or a biblical name ("maybe kind of, yeah"). He also offered several seemingly random guesses — among them, Olivia, Sophia, Emma, Eva, Isabella, Abigail, and Ruth.
"I should've worn my cup. I didn't know I was gonna get busted this hard!" the actor, next starring in The Voices, quipped of the late-night comedian's incessant guessing.
Letterman eventually gave up, and the two moved on to another subject: Reynolds' stunning wife.
"It's amazing," he gushed of life with his new family. "I'm not one for vomiting declarations of sentiment out across the airwaves, but when we had that baby, I fell more in love with my wife than I'd ever been in my entire life. I couldn't even believe it."
Even more incredible, though, is how much he loves his daughter. "I used to say to [Blake], 'I would take a bullet for you. I could never love anything as much as I love you.' I would say that to my wife," he told Letterman. "And the second I looked in that baby's eyes, I knew in that exact moment that if we were ever under attack, I would use my wife as a human shield to protect that baby."
That's not all Lively's good for, of course. "[As] the guy, I'm just like a diaper-changing facility hooked up to a life-support system. But my wife, she's breakfast, lunch, and dinner," Reynolds joked of Gossip Girl alum Lively. "She's a human Denny's, all day long and all night long. Romantic right? She's the most beautiful Denny's you've ever seen, though."
Sign up now for the Us Weekly newsletter to get breaking celebrity news, hot pics and more delivered straight to your inbox!