Three Wisest Men marked the final Hallmark movie in the holiday trilogy — but star Tyler Hynes teased it may not be the last time fans see him and his onscreen brothers Paul Campbell and Andrew Walker together.
“I mean, those guys, I obviously love them to death,” Hynes, 39, exclusively told Us Weekly while promoting his new Hallmark film, I’ll Be Seeing You. “I just saw Paul and Kim [Sustad] when I was in Vancouver, and we’re going to find ways to play around in the sand.”
The trilogy began with 2022’s Three Wise Men and a Baby, in which Luke (Walker) is stunned to discover an infant left at his firehouse with a note asking him to care for the child just before Christmas. Overwhelmed, he turns to his brothers, Stephan (Campbell) and Taylor (Hynes), for help.
Three Wiser Men and a Boy (2024) reunited the Brenner brothers as they helped Luke’s son stage an unforgettable school musical, and in Three Wisest Men (2025), they faced new challenges as Luke prepared to welcome twins with his wife.
Hynes jokingly added, “Honestly, we listen a lot to what our audience says and whether it’s the brothers or it’s some new adventure, we’ll find an excuse to disappoint everybody on screen.”
Hynes, who has starred in over 20 Hallmark movies since 2018, is now focusing on his latest project, I’ll Be Seeing You, which has the actor making his executive producer debut for the channel.
It follows an ambitious career woman [Stacey Farber] who sets out on a road trip with her grandmother [Christine Ebersole] and a charming retirement community director (Hynes) to find someone from her grandmother’s past, setting off unexpected romance and a shift in perspective on life.
“Honestly, it was a playground I wanted to create for Christine,” Hynes told Us. “I think there’s nothing more beautiful in life, and certainly love, than perspective, and what better way to sort of explore a new perspective on that than having someone like Christine be the center of the story, and have her love story be something that kind of galvanizes this blossoming relationship. I just think it’s beautiful.”
I’ll Be Seeing You premieres on Hallmark Channel Saturday, April 25, at 8 p.m. ET.
