McDonald’s appears to be playing bait-and-switch with pie lovers across the country. The fast-food chain, which has had apple pie on its menu for years, recently resurrected its less beloved pumpkin pie for fall, and several customers have said they’ve been served pumpkin pie after ordering the apple variety.
While some are pleased to see the gourd-filled pastry return to McDonald’s (it was previously on the menu in 2011 and again in 2015) others prefer the American classic, and are peeved the restaurant is seemingly trying to push another dessert on them, especially since the apple pies are just about universally loved.
Though the pie mix-ups could be purely accidental, a lot of people are reporting McDonald’s is getting its pie orders all mixed up. Check out the bevy of furious tweets below:
I was accidentally given a pumpkin pie instead of an apple pie at McDonald’s and I’m not even mad. I had completely forgotten that they carry pumpkin pies this time of year and I would’ve ordered one had I known anyways.
— Grape Soda (@ChangeChameleon) October 28, 2018
dear mcdonald’s,
for the second time this week:
PUMPKIN PIE IS NOT APPLE PIE
PUMPKIN PIE IS NOT APPLE PIE
pUMPkin PiE iS nOt APpLE PiEYOURE RUINING MY LIFE
— Sab (@SabrinaTheRebel) October 25, 2018
@McDonalds hi i ordered an apple pie then waited over 30 minutes just for them to mess up and give me a pumpkin pie.
— ybba (@tripIeabattery) November 2, 2018
Dear @McDonalds, if you're going to offer a deal that includes a pie, you should probably make sure that you actually have apple pies. Pumpkin does not equal apple. And two cookies does not equal a pie. And waiting 7.5 minutes is really not an option.
— A. Henderson-Bentley (@angelahbentley) November 5, 2018
@McDonalds accidentally gave me pumpkin pie instead of an apple and boy, oh boy, is that a surprise when you're driving down the freeway in the dark. #mybrainwasveryconfused #didntevenknowthatwasanoption
— Melly RT(R) (@melly_rtr) November 1, 2018
I ordered an Apple pie from McDonald’s but got a pumpkin pie instead? Someone help… pic.twitter.com/uBNZjdXHI6
— Lynnea Fredrickson (@OutofContextLMF) October 17, 2018
Still, seeing as how McDonald’s told Today Food the pumpkin pies consist of “pumpkin filling, a flaky pastry crust” and a sweet cinnamon sugar dusting, not everyone is against the seasonal offering, even if it is temporarily taking apple pie’s place on the menu. “One pumpkin pie from McDonald’s isn’t enough. I need 5000 more,” one fan tweeted. Added another: “I just had a pumpkin pie at McDonald’s and it was by far the best pumpkin pie I ever had.”
Tell Us: Do you prefer McDonald’s apple or pumpkin pie?