Beyond cute. Drew Barrymore joined her longtime pal Jimmy Fallon on The Tonight Show on Tuesday, Oct. 27, and played an adorable game with puppies together.

The Golden Globe winner, 40, and her Fever Pitch costar Fallon, 41, played “Pup Quiz,” an animal trivia game in which the prize is, well, a cuddle with cute puppies! The comedian has previously played the game with Kaley Cuoco and Salma Hayek.

“When does it get weird that I’m letting them lick my ears?” the Miss You Already star asked during the game, as she cuddled with two puppies, to the audible delight of the audience.

While Fallon won the first puppy — named Gary Frick Jr. — when the little pup started biting him and barking, the show host quipped, “His name isn’t Gary, his name is Cujo.”

The TV personality hasn’t had the best luck recently, as last weekend he injured his hand while being honored at Harvard by the university’s humor publication, the Lampoon, when he tripped and fell on a bottle of Jagermeister.

“Welcome to The Tonight Show,” Fallon said on Monday, Oct. 26. “I’m your host, Trippy Fallon.”

Watch the clip to see who won the puppy battle!

Sign up now for the Us Weekly newsletter to get breaking celebrity news, hot pics, and more delivered straight to your inbox!