The Bachelor's Courtney Dated Reese Witherspoon's Husband Jim Toth!

Celebrity News Feb. 10, 2012 AT 5:20PM
The Bachelor's Courtney Dated Reese Witherspoon's Husband Jim Toth! Credit: GSI Media; Jason Merritt/Getty Images

This means war, indeed!

Before she set her sights on Ben Flajnik, current Bachelor bad girl Courtney Robertson dated more than one Hollywood hunk: former Desperate Housewives star Jesse Metcalfe, Adrian Grenier…and Reese Witherspoon's husband, Jim Toth!

PHOTOS: Shocking reality TV love matches

Even Witherspoon, 36, didn't know about her man's long-ago dalliance with the catty reality star, 28 -- first learning the news Feb. 1 upon returning from a trip to Europe.

VIDEO: Catch an explosive sneak peek of the next episode of The Bachelor

But it was no big whup to the Oscar winner. "It didn't faze Reese," a source tells the new Us Weekly of the star, who wed the CAA agent, 41, nearly a year ago.

PHOTOS: Reese and Jim's happy life together

"There's no way Jim was serious about Courtney," the source sniffs of the model. "How do you go from that chick to Reese?"

How we use your email

We may use your e-mail address to send you the newsletter and offers that may interest you, on behalf of Us Weekly and its partners. For more information please read our Privacy Policy.

comments powered by Disqus