Biggest Reality TV Bombshells of 2011

Outrage Over Pia Toscano's American Idol Exit

Despite being one of the judges' favorites, Toscano was voted off April 7; she had never appeared in the bottom three prior to her elimination. "I'm gutted. You were one of the best singers in this," judge Randy Jackson said. "I'm never upset on this show and never mad, but this makes me mad."

ADVERTISEMENT

Inside Us Weekly

comments powered by Disqus