Just one month after Pieper proposed to his Bachelor Pad 3 partner-turned-girlfriend on the reunion show in September 2012, the single dad confirmed the couple had called it quits. "Unfortunately, things didn't work as we had hoped," Pieper told Wetpaint of his bond with the former VIP cocktail waitress, who first competed for Ben Flajnik's love on The Bachelor in 2010. "No one is to blame. It just ended up being a lot harder than we expected. I wish her nothing but the absolute best."