Jury Duty boasts an unconventional premise: it chronicles the inner workings of the American jury system by focusing on a juror named Ronald Gladden, but the entire trial is staged. Everyone in the trial, from the audience to the fellow jurors (who include James Marsden) to the judge, is an actor, and only Gladden — a solar contractor from San Diego — is unaware of this. While pre-planned, Jury Duty is heavily improvised, leading to plenty of hilarious scenarios as Gladden is only ever charmingly honest and earnest.
Marsden’s performance as a parody of himself is more than worthy of its multiple award nominations, and Gladden ends up the surprise breakout star of a show he didn’t even know he was on. Though a “prank show,” Gladden’s ignorance is never made to be the butt of the joke, and Jury Duty shines in its warm, light-hearted humor. This makes for extremely entertaining television, with high unpredictability that keeps you guessing. A second season, Jury Duty Presents: Company Retreat, is now streaming.