Crossover Alert! Reality Stars Who Hooked Up With Reality Stars From Other Shows

Credit: Shutterstock; ABC

Crossover Alert! Reality Stars Who Hooked Up With Reality Stars From Other Shows

Reality TV brings people together! Us Weekly has gathered the many reality stars who have mingled with other reality stars and ended in a relationship. Bravolebrities, for example, are no strangers to crossover hookups. In August 2019, Craig Conover, Shep Rose and Austen Kroll visited the cast of Summer House at their Hamptons home. During their visit, which aired on season 4 of Summer House, Conover cozied up to casemate Jules Daoud. “I was like, ‘Hey, let’s do waterslide races,’ and they were like, ‘We’re in,’” Craig recalled on the "Daily Dish" podcast at the time. “Kyle [Cooke], Paige [DeSorbo], myself, and Jules just stayed on the waterslide the whole time. And I think, as the day went on, Jules and I ended up kissing on top of the waterslide, I think. But they didn’t air any of this stuff.” After a night of partying in the Hamptons, the Sewing Down South founder spent time with Daoud in New York City. “I spent the summer in New York, so Jules and I hung out for a couple of weeks and then, whenever I was in New York, we hung out. We just had a great time and we’re still close friends,” he said at the time. “Jules and I are still really close. If I go to New York, we’ll probably hang out. But you know, nothing serious.” Conover confirmed in November 2020 that things between him and Daoud were over for good as he started seeing girlfriend Natalie Hegnauer. [jwplayer VWcMEzaQ-l3ahXupL] “I’m dating someone new now. She was great, we had a lot of fun, but she actually just texted me that she was coming to Charleston,” Conover said on Watch What Happens Live With Andy Cohen. “Unfortunately, I did not text her back, because I didn’t think that would be appropriate. I haven’t figured out how to navigate those waters yet.” Daoud isn’t the only Summer House cast member to spend time with another Bravo star. Carl Radke hooked up with Vanderpump Rules’ Scheana Shay in 2018. “We rounded third base,” she confessed to Andy Cohen on WWHL in 2019. When asked why they didn’t go “further,” Radke added, “We just — you know, we weren’t ready yet.” One year later, Shay was spotted cozying up to Southern Charm’s Rose at Brittany Cartwright and Jax Taylor’s wedding, which was filmed for season 7 of the Bravo show. "Shep and I hung out a couple times, but I never slept with him," the “Good As Gold” singer told Bravo in May 2020. "Same with Carl; hung out a couple times, never slept with him. But they're just fun guys who I met when I did Watch What Happens Live with Shep a couple years ago, and I was in a relationship, so we just had a great friendship. And then he did my podcast in L.A. and we hung out after, had too many drinks, and had a drunken makeout." Scroll through for more reality TV hookups: [podcast_block]

Credit: Shutterstock(2)

Ashley Darby and Luke Gulbranson

The Real Housewives of Potomac star hooked up with the Summer House alum after they met at BravoCon in October 2022.

Credit: Shutterstock(2)

Gizelle Bryant and Jason Cameron

The Potomac Housewife followed in her costar’s footsteps, going public with Cameron at the Summer House season 7 premiere party in February 2023.

Credit: Shutterstock; ABC

Johnny Bananas and Genevieve Parisi

The Challenge star revealed on the “Reality Rundown” podcast that he was “an eyelash away from going on Bachelor in Paradise.” Ringer’s Juliet Litman subsequently revealed on her show, “Bachelor Party,” that she “Genevieve has hooked up with our colleague, Jonathan Bananas.”

Credit: Bravo (2)

Jason Cameron and Caroline Brooks

The Winter House alum and the Real Housewives of Dubai star went to dinner in New York City in July 2022.

"Dinner was great! She’s a very intelligent and interesting woman. Shared a few dishes and had a really fun time,” Cameron told Us. "We’re getting to know each other better. Definitely hit it off at dinner and I’m hoping to see her when she’s back from vacation."

Credit: Astraea Tay

Carly Lawrence and Bennett Sipes

The former Too Hot to Handle star confirmed in December 2021 that she was dating the Love Island alum. Less than six months later, they wed during a “beautiful and really intimate” ceremony.

“We didn’t announce before we did it because we wanted it to be kept secret Just for our family and friends. We want to do a larger ceremony in the next couple of years in upstate New York since both of our families live about an hour away,” the pair told Us in May 2022. “Right now we are focused on each other our puppy and our professional adventures. Our close circle knows our love for each other. At first we wanted to elope and do it by ourselves but we decided to invite the people who know our relationship and who have watched us grow. We appreciate all the love and support and are really excited for our life together."

Credit: imageSPACE/Shutterstock; Willy Sanjuan/Invision/AP/Shutterstock

Blake Horstmann and Giannina Gibelli

In January 2022, Us confirmed that the Bachelorette alum began casually dating the former Love Is Blind star and the two are "keeping things private." That June, they went public and revealed their relationship was serious. 

Credit: Shutterstock (2)

Craig Conover and Paige DeSorbo

In October 2021, Us confirmed that the pair are "officially together" after filming Winter House earlier that year.

"Their friendship turned into a relationship as they've spent more time together in recent weeks," a source told Us at the time. They are still going strong as of July 2022.

Credit: MTV

Faith Stowers and Kyle Christie

Faith Stowers is best known for hooking up with Jax Taylor on Vanderpump Rules, but when she joined MTV’s The Challenge: Final Reckoning in 2018, she embarked on a relationship with the star of UK’s Ex on the Beach, Kyle Christie. The relationship didn’t last long – once she was eliminated, he began hooking up with Challenge vet Ashley Mitchell.

Credit: MediaPunch/Shutterstock; Karolina Wojtasik/Bravo

Craig Conover and Jules Daoud

The Southern Charm star and the Summer House newcomer hooked up during his trip to the Hamptons in August 2019, which was filmed for season 4 of the summer series. 

Credit: Neil Mockford/GC Images; Jim Spellman/WireImage

Stephanie Pratt and Derek Peth

The Hills: New Beginnings star and the Bachelor in Paradise alum were set up on a blind date by mutual friend Wells Adams in March 2019. The duo hit it off and locked lips three times during the outing. In fact, Pratt told Adams on the March 25 episode of their “Pratt Cast” podcast that she would “absolutely” go on a second date with Peth — and he feels the same way! “I was very attracted to you and we had tons of fun, and in any case like that, of course I would want to see that person again,” the banker, who ended his engagement to former BIP costar Taylor Nolan in June 2018, told the MTV star. She agreed, “Yeah, ditto. We did have the best date.”

Credit: Charley Gallay/Getty Images; Rodin Eckenroth/Getty Images

Scheana Shay and Robby Hayes

After the Vanderpump Rules star was spotted with Bachelorette alum Robby Hayes in Hawaii in May 2018, Shay told Us exclusively that fans will see her go on a date with a member of Bachelor Nation during season 7 of the Bravo show. “You’ll see me single the entire summer. I go on quite a few dates. I will just say that I have my Bachelorette moment on the show this summer,” Shay told Us in September 2018. “When I said I had my Bachelorette moment, I mean because I went out with more than one person who had been on the show The Bachelorette. And you’ll see one of those this summer.”

Credit: MTV

Angela Babicz and Johnny Bananas

Speaking of The Challenge: Final Reckoning, longtime player Johnny Bananas Devenanzio cozied up to Angela Babicz during the 2018 season. Angela is best known for appearing on season 15 of Bad Girls Club.

Credit: Jerod Harris/Getty Images for LG

Juliette Porter and Robby Hayes

The Siesta Key star revealed that she was dating the Bachelor in Paradise alum with a photo of the pair kissing on Instagram in May 2019. She captioned the snap with a blue heart and a tropical fish emoji. Hayes also shared a photo of himself with his new flame and other pals — including Porter’s costar Kelsey Owens — on Instagram. “When the sun shines, we’ll shine together,” he wrote.

Credit: Jean Baptiste Lacroix/WireImage

Jayde Nicole and Brody Jenner

Before Jayde Nicole appeared on The Hills in a messy relationship with Brody Jenner, the model filmed a pilot for The Girls Next Door spinoff, The Bunny House. She also appeared in multiple episodes of Holly’s World. She and Jenner dated for over a year until splitting in December 2009.

Credit: E!

Nikki Bella and Peter Kraus

Brie Bella set up her twin sister, Nikki Bella, on a date with Peter Kraus during season 4 of Total Bellas. Fans got their first glimpse of the outing, which appeared to include a kiss, during a trailer for the E! series released in November 2018. Kraus turned red when asked by Us Weekly about Nikki amid the romance speculation. 

Credit: Courtesy of Danielle Maltby/Instagram

Paulie Calafiore and Danielle Maltby

After she appeared on season 21 The Bachelor and season 4 of Bachelor in Paradise, Danielle Maltby began dating another reality star, Big Brother 18 alum Paul Calafiore, in January 2018. The two were introduced by their publicist and immediately hit it off. However, after he appeared on The Challenge: Final Reckoning, the two split in summer 2018 as he began dating Challenge star Cara Maria Sorbello.

Credit: Charles Sykes/Bravo/NBCU Photo Bank via Getty Images; Mike Coppola/Getty Images for MTV

Shep Rose and Stacy London

Southern Charm’s Rose one made out with his close friend, What Not to Wear alum Stacy London, Andy Cohen revealed on Watch What Happens Live in 2016. The two have been friends for years and continue to be post-hookup. 

Credit: Charles Sykes/Bravo/NBCU Photo Bank via Getty Images; Paul Archuleta/Getty Images

Carl Radke and Scheana Shay

Shay told Andy Cohen in March 2018 that they had a “drunken make out once.”