After the 37-year-old Beauty and the Beast actor posted an old photo of himself with Jake Gyllenhaal from a movie set to Instagram, the 35-year-old actress swooped in to steal his thunder.
“#tbt Wow. Here’s an oldie but a goodie. #jakegyllenhaal and I behind the scenes during #loveandotherdrugs,” Gad captioned the pic, to which Hathaway — who starred alongside them in the 2010 romantic comedy-drama — chimed in.
“I’m not sure if you’ll remember me but I was in Love and Other Drugs with you,” the Princess Diaries star wrote. “My name is Annie? Anyway, I hope you are well!” She even added a nod to being a Gad superfan. “(Please like my comment, it would mean so much to me!)”
But the Frozen voice actor wasn’t going to let Hathaway get the last laugh. “@annehathaway please reach out to my agent,” he responded to her comment. “That’s where I have my fan mail sent. Thank you!!”
And fans of the movie, in which Hathaway played a Parkinson’s patient who got a chance at love with a pharmaceutical salesman played by Gyllenhaal, were happy to get in on the fun. (Gad played Gyllenhaal’s brother, Josh Randall, in the Edward Zwick-directed film.)
“I love love love that movie! You’re hysterical! Jake Gyllenhaal is well…Jake Gyllenhaal. And @annehathaway is extraordinary like always!” one commenter wrote.
Another simply added: “Anne Hathaway’s comment and joshs response is killing me.
Sign up now for the Us Weekly newsletter to get breaking celebrity news, hot pics and more delivered straight to your inbox!