The Best Clothing Subscription Boxes for Women To Help You Create a Never-Ending Closet

What makes Stitch Fix our top pick for clothing boxes? Primarily, it’s the consistency. We love that the items in every box help elevate the customer’s style, paying attention to their likes and dislikes. We also like that the $20 styling fee gets credited toward any purchases you make (if you keep any of the items in your box), and you get an additional 25% off if you keep all the items in your box.

Of course, there’s always a chance that you receive pieces you don’t like. This is because StitchFix uses an algorithm to select clothing to add to your box, so your stylist has limited options from which to choose when making final selections. (To help increase the odds that you’ll receive items you enjoy, try expressing what you like rather than what you dislike in your quiz — stylists say this is more helpful.) In addition, the clothing pictures in the style quiz aren’t up to date with the latest trends, which may make it difficult for you to indicate your preferred styles.

If you’ve always wanted to try out high-end clothing without paying full price — or being stuck with unique pieces that you never wear again — Armoire is our top pick for you. The most affordable plan starts at $79 per month, and contains four items. Wear them as many times as you like that month, then return when your new items arrive. We also love that Armoire shows you the faces of your stylists, so you can see that they are real! Plus, you have final say over what goes in your box.

On the other hand, these boxes are quite pricey, and buying any of the items in your box is another sizable investment. Before you buy a subscription, it’s also a little difficult to get a sense of all the available items. Not many items are tailored to petites, either.

It’s not easy thinking up different outfits for work each week, but Gwynnie Bee makes it easy. This rental-based subscription box lets you pick the items you want to rent (for as long as you want), then return or exchange them, with free shipping included both ways. The styles are fun and flirty, with classic pieces here and there. We also love that they, like most rental services, take care of washing and dry cleaning — another weekly chore that’s no longer on your to-do list.

A word of caution: The price goes up quickly for this subscription rental box, because you pay extra depending on how many pieces you want to rent at any given time. If you have a one-piece rental plan, it costs $49, but if you have a two-piece plan, it costs $69. In addition, buyers found their item selection to be small and the pieces similar, so it was hard to find a lot of variety.

If you enjoy trying new business-friendly items but don’t want to keep them, Le Tote is a great solution. We love that available pieces range from classic professional to elegant and playful, so you can find staple items while exploring items that interest you. The biggest difference between Le Tote and other rental-based boxes? If you decide to keep any of the items, you get an impressive 50% off the retail price (most brands give you a maximum of 25% off).

Though you get to choose your own clothes, reviewers note that it is sometimes hard to find items in the catalog that aren’t out of stock or unavailable. In addition, their accessory selection is limited. Lastly, it takes some time for Le Tote to process and ship your order — it’s longer than most subscription services.

With a Rent the Runway subscription box, you pay a monthly fee to receive five items each month from a catalog of designer clothing. We love that you get to select every item in your box, and shipping is speedy. Keep items as long as you want, assuming you continue to pay the monthly fee. If you don’t want to purchase an entire box, you can also reserve just one item for a specific date on your calendar.

The downsides: Since Rent the Runway specializes in luxury items, this subscription is expensive. Be wary of renting popular items: They tend to show signs of visible wear, and some buyers have even noticed that they don’t always smell clean. (Try shopping in the “what’s new” section if you’re cautious.)

When it comes to athletic clothing, a subscription service that lets you keep all the items (rather than receiving rented items that everyone, well, exercised in) is important. The Fabletics VIP Membership charges you a monthly fee which gets converted into credits. You can then use credits to purchase items from both Fabletics and Yitty. Other perks: Shipping is free, and you’ll get access to the Fabletics FIT app.

Bear in mind that the monthly charges are automatic, so set reminders for yourself between the 1st and the 5th of the month if you want to cancel. Otherwise, it can be hard to get a refund.

If you love getting new athletic wear but don’t like shopping for it every month, Ellie is the subscription box for you. For a monthly fee, the company will send you three items monthly based on your preferences. Returns are free if something doesn’t fit well, and shipping is included. We love that it’s easy to pause or cancel your subscription.

The downsides: A few buyers think the athletic wear is not suitable for high-intensity workouts, and works better for yoga or lounging. Also, the brand no longer sends boxes with two or five items (instead of three), unless you have been a member since before September 1, 2022.

Hoping to dip your toe into the world of intimate wear without committing to one or two styles? We recommend Adore Me, which will send you a box each month with four to seven items. You get seven days to try on everything, then send back what you don’t like. If you keep anything, the $20 styling fee goes toward your purchases. Bonus: You can also opt to receive activewear, everyday bras and panties and swimwear.

However, buyers have noticed that the styles tend to repeat themselves in subsequent boxes, so they may feel a bit bored. Plus, the quality of certain items may not be ideal — some customers find them uncomfortable.

Here’s what we like about the XTRA VIP Membership: You get to select the lingerie you want to buy (at any time), and the monthly fee gives you access to exclusive lingerie sets. We also love that the brand is size inclusive and features a wide range of lingerie types and colors. Your membership credits (which you receive after making a monthly payment) can also be used to purchase loungewear and athletic clothing.

Unfortunately, some customers have found that the VIP membership isn’t worth the monthly fee, either because the sizing was incorrect or the quality wasn’t what they expected. You also have to be quick to cancel your membership before the 6th of the month, or it can be hard to get your money back.

What we love about Dia & Co: All of the items are tailored for plus-size bodies (size 14 and up). So, you don’t have to worry that the company won’t have your size or that the items will be cut strangely. We also love that the company offers six different boxes that change based on the season.

What we don’t like: The items are expensive, and buying everything in one box can cost between $200 and $300. In addition, some repeat customers note that the style choices and quality seem to diminish in subsequent boxes. You may even find that some of the items in your box are sold for lower prices on other sites.

Tired of cuffing your pants, rolling your sleeves, and getting everything tailored? Short Story is a great solution if you’re petite (5’5” or under) and want to get into subscription clothing boxes. Every box contains five petite-friendly items, from tops to jeans to dresses, and it includes shipping.

Unfortunately, some buyers have complained about the quality of the clothing in the past year, noting that seams on pants come undone and some of the fabrics are thin and see-through. In addition, a few customers have struggled to find styles in their boxes that they truly like.

With the Italic Bold Membership, you pay a flat fee of $60 and receive four $15 vouchers (which can be used every three months), free shipping, and free returns on any purchases made that year. Anytime you need retail therapy, you can purchase one or more items of your choice from the Italic website — that includes luxury office wear, lounge wear, active wear and accessories. Just make sure to spend that $15 voucher within three months, or you lose it.

We think this membership is great if you were already planning to shop for new, high-quality items each month. However, it may not be a good fit if you want to cut down on your monthly spending and don’t want to commit to a year of the membership. Italic Bold items are expensive, so $15 off every three months doesn’t go very far.

If you want to explore the boundaries of your wardrobe and find new, interesting pieces that still speak to you, Nuuly is the way to go. This subscription box includes six items from well-known brands like Anthropologie, Farm Rio and Live Nation. In addition, shipping and returns are included and you don’t have to pay for slight lateness in returning rentals or minor damage.

While there is a lot to love about Nuuly, it is still an expensive rental service. The monthly price has left some buyers feeling like the boxes aren’t worth it because they had a hard time getting the items they really wanted or finding clothing that fit well.

Hoping to stay on trend in the world of swimwear every summer? Think ahead with the Beachly monthly subscription. Every box contains six Beachly items, including bathing suits, towels, jewelry and skincare, all of which is selected based on your preferences. We also love that boxes are shipped seasonally or annually, so you won’t waste money on bathing suits in the winter.

The downsides: Some buyers have felt that the value of their box didn’t add up to $49.