It was over before it started. The Nightcrawler actor had a brief fling with Friday Night Lights alum Minka Kelly in June 2012. "Minka wasn't into Jake when he first pursued her," a mutual pal of the two actors exclusively told Us. But after romancing Wilmer Valderrama, Kelly "decided to give Jake another chance." The spark quickly fizzled, however. "It was never serious," the insider added.