Carson, 26, said there were “so many” former contenders worthy of being named the best of the best. However, she admitted to being “a little bit biased” when selecting her choice.
“I would probably say Alfonso [Ribeiro]’s the best or probably Jordan Fisher,” the So You Think You Can Dance alum exclusively told Us Weekly on Monday, August 3. “I think Jordan Fisher is probably the best contestant, what you’ve seen on the show.”
“I know Kim Kardashian was really rough,” she confessed about the 39-year-old reality star, before adding that the shoes Master P, 50, wore in the ballroom “didn’t work” and that he “kept his hat on” the entire time.
Carson joined Dancing With the Stars in 2013 as a troupe dancer. That next year, she was bumped up to professional dancer status for season 18 and was partnered with Cody Simpson. She achieved her first win with Ribeiro, 48, in the season that followed.
Out of the many partners she’s had on the show, there was one contestant, in particular, who proved to be a pleasant surprise: Frankie Muniz. She was paired with the Malcolm in the Middle alum, 34, in 2017 for season 25. They ended the competition in third place.
“I didn’t know how good he [would] be,” she admitted. “I think he obviously didn’t have the natural ability and he’ll tell you that, but I think he was able to learn very quickly and we made it all the way to the finale. So, obviously, something we were doing was working, but he definitely surprised me.”
If Carson were to pick her favorite routine from over the years, Derek Hough’s contemporary number with Bindi Irwin hits the top of her list. In November 2015, the pair performed an emotional dance dedicated to the 22-year-old Australia native’s late father, Steve Irwin, who died in 2006.
Carson said she “will always remember” that performance. “I don’t know if that’s the best in history, but that’s definitely something that, like, imprinted on me,” she explained.
With reporting by Christina Garibaldi
Hear the Us Weekly editors break down the most surprising celebrity births during the pandemic in under 2 minutes!
For access to all our exclusive celebrity videos and interviews – Subscribe on YouTube!