Already have an account?
Get back to the

Blake Horstmann Believes Pieper and Brendan Tried to ‘Bamboozle’ Producers, Calls Chris and Alana Victims of ‘Mob Mentality’

Bachelor in Paradise duos Pieper James and Brendan Morais and Alana Milne and Chris Conran are both under fire for their pre-show relationships, but only one couple has been kicked off the beach (so far). Blake Horstmann joins Us Weekly’s “Here for the Right Reasons” podcast to discuss what likely went down behind the scenes on the Monday, September 6, and Tuesday, September 7, episodes of the ABC series.

Related: Pieper and Brendan's Relationship: Everything We Know

“I don’t know what the plan is and whatever plan they had planned, it didn’t work, like, they muffed it,” Blake began of Pieper and Brendan, who were first linked two months before production started in Mexico. “I think maybe they had a plan going in, but once you’re in that environment — and she’s been quarantining for a minute, close to, like, seven or eight days with COVID [protocols] and everything and then [the] first few days on the beach — those producers can get to you. … The producer over five days, could’ve somehow convinced her, like, ‘Don’t waste your time with the other guys. Just go for Brendan. Don’t waste your time.’ By the fifth day, she was [probably] like, ‘That was my idea!’”

Blake Horstmann Believes Pieper and Brendan Tried to ‘Bamboozle’ Producers
Blake Horstmann, Pieper James, and Brendan Morais. Drew Altizer Photography/Shutterstock; ABC/Craig Sjodin(2)

In addition to coming under fire for seemingly using Natasha Parker to keep Brendan on the beach, Pieper and the commercial roofer were caught discussing follower counts, appearing to admit they were on the show for fame.

Related: Victoria F. Calls Brendan a ‘Sick F--k’ Over Natasha Drama

“These conversations happen and they’re not the first people to have a conversation on the beach about followers and who has the most followers, blah, blah, blah, blah, but this is the first time they’ve ever aired anything like that, which was kind of shocking,” Blake told Us. “Brendan having a girlfriend back home would have been enough, like, I think he would have been the ‘villain.’ And that’s why I think that the producers were like, ‘No, no, no, no, you try to bamboozle us, we’re going to destroy you.'”

While Pieper and Brendan joined the group after upsetting Natasha with their romance, Alana and Chris, for their part, were asked to leave Mexico by their castmates after rumors suggested they had a pre-show plan, too. The group kicked them off in defense of Jessenia Cruz, who was also dating Chris.

“I think it was mob mentality,” Blake told Us. “I saw it firsthand and felt it firsthand. If producers are getting in your ear about how bad somebody is or what they did was so bad, there’s this mob mentality. And they just wanted to get Chris and I’ll never understand why. Chris was trying to talk to Jessenia alone and Joe [Amabile] came over and wouldn’t let them talk. And then Riley [Christian] came over and people were calling them ‘scum, horrible human.’ I’m like, ‘Relax, he kissed a girl in front of another girl and yeah, that’s messed up, but it’s Paradise, like, that happens all the time.’ … I think it was blown [out of proportion]. Where was that energy for Brendan and Pieper?”

Related: Status Check! Bachelor Nation Couples Who Are Still Going Strong

Blake added, “In my opinion, Alana did nothing wrong. She went down there, the man she liked was there and then she went after him, like, that’s the name of the game down there. So there was just a lot of hate that I think didn’t need to be thrown at Alana — and Chris, for that matter.”

For more from Blake, including his reaction to watching ex Becca Kufrin date Thomas Jacobs, listen to the “Here for the Right Reasons” podcast.

Episode 90

Inside What Really Happened Between Jessenia, Alana and Chris in San Diego
San Diego is being dubbed the “new Stagecoach” by some Bachelor in Paradise viewers after Alana Milne and Chris Conran were accused of having a pre-show relationship amid a love triangle with Jessenia Cruz, but...
Flip podcast card

Episode 91

Connor Saeli: Several ‘BiP’ Couples Have Similar Stories to Pieper, Brendan
Pieper James and Brendan Morais are under fire for their alleged plan to come on Bachelor in Paradise for followers and fame, but according to Bachelor Nation’s Connor Saeli — they aren’t the first duo to...
Flip podcast card

Episode 92

BiP’s Tia Booth Provides Context for ’Rage’ Toward Blake Monar
Bachelor alum Elyse Dehlbom joined Us Weekly’s “Here for the Right Reasons” podcast to recap the Tuesday, September 21, episode — and all signs point to there being more to the story when it comes...
Flip podcast card

Episode 93

Kelley Flanagan on Whether ‘BiP’ Producers Planted Phone Ivan Hall Found
Kelley Flanagan recapped the Tuesday, September 28, episode of Bachelor in Paradise on Us Weekly’s “Here for the Right Reasons” podcast — and she’s team Ivan Hall! Related: All...
Flip podcast card

Episode 94

‘BiP’ Finale Recap With Amanda Hirsch: Which Couples Will Go the Distance?
It wouldn’t be a finale in Bachelor Nation without predictions about the future! Instagram creator and host of the “Not Skinny But Not Fat” podcast Amanda Hirsch joins Us Weekly’s “Here for the...
Flip podcast card
Got a Tip form close button
Got a tip for US?
We're All Ears for Celebrity Buzz!