Already have an account?
Get back to the

Caila Quinn Recalls Nearly Being ‘The Bachelorette’: I Tried on the Dresses JoJo Fletcher Ended Up Wearing

A sliding doors moment in Bachelor Nation. As she prepares to walk down the aisle, Caila Quinn reflected on nearly being the season 12 Bachelorette during an appearance on Us Weekly’s “Here for the Right Reasons” podcast.

Related: Contestants Who Were in Talks to Be the Bachelor or Bachelorette

“It was so long ago. And it did happen for a moment. And it was fleeting, but at the end of the day, it worked out. And you know what, I was so young at the time,” the 30-year-old reality TV personality exclusively told Us. “But yes, I was temporarily in the running for the Bachelorette, and they filmed in my hometown. And it was kind of crazy because for six months, they would fly me to L.A. to do fittings and for meetings and stuff like that. So I tried on a couple of dresses and gowns that JoJo [Fletcher] wore on her season. I was like, ‘That blue dress looks good on you girl!’ I tried that same sparkly gown.”

Caila Quinn Recalls Dress Fittings Filming Before JoJo Bachelorette Swap
Caila Quinn and JoJo Fletcher. Scott Roth/Invision/AP/Shutterstock; Frederick Breedon/PictureGroup/Shutterstock

Caila and JoJo, 30, finished as Ben Higgins‘ second and first runner-up, respectively, during season 20 of The Bachelor, which aired in 2016.

“It [was] a little bizarre,” she said of seeing JoJo’s promos start to air during the summer of 2016. “And it’s, like, you kind of look and watch somebody else and you’re like, ‘That’s the life I could have lived.’ It’s kind of like when your ex moves on and gets married. You have this moment where you pause and you’re like, ‘Whoa, I mean, I know I’ve moved on, but that could have been my life.’ So it’s kind of crazy.”

Related: Bachelor Nation Stars Who Found Love After the Show

Caila confirmed she filmed scenes in her hometown of Cleveland, Ohio.

“I wish they would share the footage because we had, like, 100 of my Filipino family together for the first episode that we recorded. And we had this giant Filipino barbecue where there was, like, a pig on a spit. And it felt like My Big Fat Greek Wedding, but my big fat Filipino wedding,” she told Us. “My mom has five brothers and they’re all, like, telling these funny stories. And that was just a lot of culture there that I think hasn’t been represented. And I’ll be honest, a lot of America doesn’t even know where the Philippines is or what Filipino culture is. I think Asian is grouped together as one ethnicity and there’s really just so much more to it out there than just like, you know, Chinese and Japanese.”

She continued: “They normally don’t film, like, a first few episodes with somebody and then take it back. But I understand why. I think what they do is they usually have two people that they’re choosing between, just in case one of the girls meets someone because, like, what if JoJo had met and fallen in love with somebody in her neighborhood? They could never have helped that and [it’s a] TV show, they need someone as a backup, so I get it.”

Related: Former ‘Bachelor’ and ‘Bachelorette’ Leads: Where Are They Now?

While JoJo met fiancé Jordan Rodgers during season 12 of The Bachelorette, Caila is marrying fiancé Nick Burrello later this month.

“I’m super happy. I’m getting married in four weeks,” Caila added. “I really believe in fate. And if you watch [JoJo and Jordan] together, I watch their home renovation show and they’re hosting these things, and their chemistry is, like, you can’t match it and they were meant to meet that way. And I love that. I hope that for everyone.”

Ben, for his part, proposed to Lauren Bushnell during the season 20 finale, but they called it quits in May 2017. While she is currently expecting her first child with husband Chris Lane, the Alone in Plain Sight author is engaged to Jess Clarke.

“I had no idea [he was going to pick Lauren]. I was 23. I was like, ‘Oh, definitely me!’” Caila told Us about Ben’s season. “Meanwhile, he’s taking her on secret, like, long walks that are, like, two hours long during a group date. And I was like, ‘Don’t worry, he can come back to you.’ No idea.”

For more from Caila, including why she hated filming Bachelor in Paradise, listen to Us Weekly’s “Here for the Right Reasons” podcast.

Episode 72

Bennett Jordan on What Could've Changed His 'Bachelorette' Ending
As he may or may not be gearing up for a stint on Bachelor in Paradise, Bennett Jordan reflected on his time on Tayshia Adams’ season of The Bachelorette during an exclusive interview with Us Weekly, including his decision...
Flip podcast card

Episode 73

Jason Tartick Teases What He Saw on Set of Katie’s 'Bachelorette' Set
After visiting the set of Katie Thurston’s season of The Bachelorette, Jason Tartick teased that Kaitlyn Bristowe and Tayshia Adams might steal the show. Related: ‘The Bachelorette’ Season...
Flip podcast card

Episode 74

Why BiP's Raven Gates, Adam Gottschalk Ruled Out a TV Wedding
Raven Gates and Adam Gottschalk didn’t get engaged after meeting on the beach in Mexico — a move they think helped them become one of the rare Bachelor in Paradise success stories. Related: Raven...
Flip podcast card

Episode 75

Katie’s ‘Bachelorette’ Season by the Numbers: Average Age and More Trends
Season 17 of The Bachelorette kicks off on Monday, June 7, and Suzana, who runs @BachelorData on Instagram, broke down Katie Thurston’s journey by the numbers on Us Weekly’s “Here for the Right Reasons”...
Flip podcast card

Episode 76

Katie Thurston Teases She’s ‘Pleasantly Surprised’ by Virgin Contestant
There’s still a lot to unpack from the season 17 premiere of The Bachelorette — and Us Weekly is breaking it all down on our “Here for the Right Reasons” podcast. Related: Inside the...
Flip podcast card
Got a Tip form close button
Got a tip for US?
We're All Ears for Celebrity Buzz!