During a group date on the Monday, May 20, episode of the ABC reality dating series, Luke, 24, shared his feelings for Hannah, also 24, while speaking on stage at a “Mr. Right” competition. “I can’t believe I’m saying this right now — this is so crazy because it’s so soon — but I can’t hide it. Hannah, I’m genuinely starting to fall in love with you,” he announced, much to the beauty pageant titleholder’s delight.
Hannah ended up crowning the import-export manager as the winner of the contest, but some viewers at home were taken aback by his early admission.
“Hannah: ‘Luke says he’s staring to fall in love with me, and I believe him.’ AYE HANNAH, LET ME SELL YOU TICKETS TO THIS AWESOME MUSIC FESTIVAL ON THIS ISLAND,” one fan tweeted, referencing the disastrous 2017 Fyre Festival.
Hannah: "Luke says he's starting to fall in love with me, and I believe him."
AYE HANNAH, LET ME SELL YOU TICKETS TO THIS AWESOME MUSIC FESTIVAL ON THIS ISLAND…#thebachelorette
— Diggy Moreland (@diggymoreland) May 21, 2019
Another member of Bachelor Nation uploaded a picture of a box filled with actual red flags. “Found a rare unseen before pic of Luke from #TheBachelorette,” the tweet read.
— Sam (@ravenwillowrain) May 21, 2019
One concerned viewer jokingly compared Luke to Penn Badgley’s sociopath You character, Joe Goldberg, tweeting, “Is Luke P. using #TheBachelorette as his audition for #YOU season 2?”
— Kristen Baldwin (@KristenGBaldwin) May 21, 2019
Former Bachelor leads and contestants also weighed in. The Bachelorette season 14 favorite Connor Obrochta tweeted, “Who doesn’t believe one word Luke says” alongside a GIF of the Mean Girls cast raising their hands. The Bachelor season 21 star Nick Viall, meanwhile, wrote, “Luke P seems like the type of guy who is capable of being really s–ty and then defends his action by saying ‘Only God can judge me.’ Not true Luke, I’m judging you right now. Also, i hate your tie.”
— Connor Obrochta (@CObrochta33) May 21, 2019
Also, Luke P seems like the type of guy who is capable of being really shitty and then defends his action by saying “Only God can judge me.” Not true Luke, I’m judging you right now. Also, i hate your tie. #theBachelorette
— Nick Viall (@viallnicholas28) May 14, 2019
See more reactions below!
— Liss (@lissenbetch) May 21, 2019
— Katelyn Rath (@katelyn_rath) May 21, 2019
— NeilLame (@neil_lame) May 21, 2019
The Bachelorette airs on ABC Mondays at 8 p.m. ET.
Sign up now for the Us Weekly newsletter to get breaking celebrity news, hot pics and more delivered straight to your inbox!