Bachelor Nation Stars Who Look-Alike: Susie Evans and Hannah Brown and More

Credit: ABC; Shutterstock

Bachelor Nation Stars Who Look-Alike: Susie Evans and Hannah Brown and More

Seeing double? After two decades — and more than 40 seasons combined — fans have seen it all on The Bachelor and The Bachelorette. In fact, some viewers think that the ABC series is beginning to feel redundant, at least when it comes to the contestants, many of whom have started to look alike. The franchise took the doppelgänger trend to a whole new level in 2016 when they cast identical twins Emily and Haley Ferguson to compete on Ben Higgins’ season of the series. The women, however, didn’t appear to have an issue with trying to woo the same man. "We're just not very competitive," Haley told E! News in January 2016. "We have a mutual understanding of what's going on here. So we discussed this before we even came on to meet Ben." Emily, for her part, claimed, "We've talked about it, it doesn't really matter. Whoever Ben clicks with is just the better twin, obviously! It's up to Ben, it's not up to us!" While the Ferguson sisters are actually related, there are a few more look-alike contestants that have caught Bachelor Nation’s attention over the years. Season 26’s Susie Evans, for example, caused a stir on night one, when viewers couldn’t get over how much she resembled former Bachelorette Hannah Brown. [jwplayer 2yy8vYiA-zhNYySv2] “Hannah Brown? Is that you?” one Twitter user asked in January 2022, sharing side-by-side photos of the former Miss Virginia and the Dancing With the Stars champion. Another fan tweeted, “You’re telling me that’s NOT Hannah Brown?!” The women appeared to be separated at birth based on their honey-brown locks, wavy hairstyles, pageant pasts and big smiles with similar dimple placement. When it comes to Bachelorette contestants, season 15’s Luke Stone appears to be a spitting image of Nick Viall, who competed on both seasons 10 and 11 of the series, before helming The Bachelor in 2016. During his time on Bachelor in Paradise, Luke S. was continually compared to Nick, so much so, that season 6 costar Haley called him "the poor man's Nick Viall.” However, the “Viall Files” podcast host didn’t see the resemblance. In September 2019, Nick joked about the difference between the men, captioning a photo of himself, “Not Luke S.” Luke replied, “Correct.” The Wisconsin native then pointed out that Luke is a “guy with a beard and curly hair,” adding that “multiple people” told Nick that the political consultant “looks nothing like me in person.” Scroll down to see which Bachelor Nation stars could be mistaken for twins: [podcast_block]

Credit: ABC; Shutterstock

Bachelor Nation Stars Who Look-Alike: Susie Evans and Hannah Brown and More

Seeing double? After two decades — and more than 40 seasons combined — fans have seen it all on The Bachelor and The Bachelorette. In fact, some viewers think that the ABC series is beginning to feel redundant, at least when it comes to the contestants, many of whom have started to look alike. The franchise took the doppelgänger trend to a whole new level in 2016 when they cast identical twins Emily and Haley Ferguson to compete on Ben Higgins’ season of the series. The women, however, didn’t appear to have an issue with trying to woo the same man. "We're just not very competitive," Haley told E! News in January 2016. "We have a mutual understanding of what's going on here. So we discussed this before we even came on to meet Ben." Emily, for her part, claimed, "We've talked about it, it doesn't really matter. Whoever Ben clicks with is just the better twin, obviously! It's up to Ben, it's not up to us!" While the Ferguson sisters are actually related, there are a few more look-alike contestants that have caught Bachelor Nation’s attention over the years. Season 26’s Susie Evans, for example, caused a stir on night one, when viewers couldn’t get over how much she resembled former Bachelorette Hannah Brown. [jwplayer 2yy8vYiA-zhNYySv2] “Hannah Brown? Is that you?” one Twitter user asked in January 2022, sharing side-by-side photos of the former Miss Virginia and the Dancing With the Stars champion. Another fan tweeted, “You’re telling me that’s NOT Hannah Brown?!” The women appeared to be separated at birth based on their honey-brown locks, wavy hairstyles, pageant pasts and big smiles with similar dimple placement. When it comes to Bachelorette contestants, season 15’s Luke Stone appears to be a spitting image of Nick Viall, who competed on both seasons 10 and 11 of the series, before helming The Bachelor in 2016. During his time on Bachelor in Paradise, Luke S. was continually compared to Nick, so much so, that season 6 costar Haley called him "the poor man's Nick Viall.” However, the “Viall Files” podcast host didn’t see the resemblance. In September 2019, Nick joked about the difference between the men, captioning a photo of himself, “Not Luke S.” Luke replied, “Correct.” The Wisconsin native then pointed out that Luke is a “guy with a beard and curly hair,” adding that “multiple people” told Nick that the political consultant “looks nothing like me in person.” Scroll down to see which Bachelor Nation stars could be mistaken for twins: [podcast_block]

Credit: ABC (2)

Shanae Ankney and Cassidy Timbrooks

The recruiter and the executive assistant made fans do a double take while watching them both compete on season 26 of the ABC dating series in 2022.

Credit: ABC (2)

Clayton Echards and Jesse Palmer

The season 26 lead was mistaken on multiple occasions by fans for the show’s host, who looked for love himself on season 5 of the show in 2004.

Credit: ABC; Shutterstock

Susie Evans and Hannah Brown

Susie, who began dating Clayton after her season 26 exit in 2022, was mistaken for the Alabama native the moment she stepped out of the limo. Hannah, for her part, became the Bachelorette on season 15 in 2019 after previously vying for Colton Underwood’s heart on season 23 of The Bachelor.

Credit: Courtesy of Luke Stone/Instagram; ABC

Luke Stone and Nick Viall

Bachelor Nation thought season 15 Bachelorette contestant Luke was Nick's long-lost twin when he first arrived at Bachelor Mansion in 2019. Many of Luke's Instagram photos resemble the season 21 Bachelor lead’s own snaps.

Credit: Courtesy of Alexis Waters/Instagram; Shutterstock

Alexis Waters and Jade Roper

The season 21 Bachelor contestant and the season 19 alum bear a striking resemblance to each other. Both women later appeared on Bachelor in Paradise, with Waters starring on season 4 and Roper finding love with now-husband Tanner Tolbert on season 2.

Credit: Courtesy of Victoria Paul/Instagram; Courtesy of Demi Burnett/Instagram

Victoria Paul and Demi Burnett

Fans argued that the blonde-haired reality stars could be mistaken for one another, especially when wearing glasses. Victoria and Demi, who competes on season 24 and season 23, respectively, were also featured on Bachelor in Paradise. While Demi was a fixture on season 6 of the spinoff, she later returned for season 7, which is when she briefly crossed over with Victoria.

Credit: ABC

Wells Adams and Joe Amabile

Joe was briefly part of Becca Kufrin’s Bachelorette season in 2018, but it didn’t take long for viewers to note how much the Chicago native looked like season 12 contestant Wells. The men continued to fuel the separated-at-birth chatter when they were both seen on Bachelor in Paradise season 5 while Wells was bartending and Joe was looking for love.

Credit: Shutterstock (2)

Connor Obrochta and Jordan Rodgers

The season 14 contestant turned heads when it became apparent that his jawline and overall look was very reminiscent of Jordan, who won season 12 of The Bachelorette and got engaged to JoJo Fletcher in 2016.

Credit: Courtesy of Jen Saviano/Instagram; Courtesy of Sharleen Joynt/Instagram

Jen Saviano and Sharleen Joynt

The Florida native — who appeared on season 20 of the ABC series and two seasons of BiP — has similar features to Sharleen, who fans met during season 18 of the show. The ladies’ long, brown hair and big smiles make it easy to see why fans thought they could be related.

Credit: Linkedin; Shutterstock

Rachel Tchen and Melissa Rycroft

While Rachel was eliminated on week four during season 20 of The Bachelor, her sweet smile and bubbly personality were hard to forget. In fact, many viewers compared her to Melissa, who despite winning season 13 of the show, ended up alone after Bachelor Jason Mesnick called off their engagement and began seeing his runner-up, Molly Malaney.

Credit: Courtesy of Andi Dorfman/Instagram

Amanda Stanton and Andi Dorfman

Amanda looks like a blonde-haired version of her real-life pal Andi. The California native competed on season 20 of the dating show before appearing on Bachelor in Paradise in 2016, which is when she got engaged to Andi's ex-fiancé Josh Murray. The duo split in December of that year.

Andi, for her part, competed on season 18 of The Bachelor before becoming the lead on season 10 of The Bachelorette. She split from winner Josh six months after he proposed on the show’s 2014 finale.

Credit: Shutterstock

Emily and Haley Ferguson

Viewers met the Ferguson twins — who are very hard to tell apart — on season 20 of the reality series while they both competed for Ben's final rose. Haley was sent home during week four, while Emily wasn’t eliminated until week seven. The sisters later appeared on seasons 3 and 4 of Bachelor in Paradise. Haley tried her hand at a third season, briefly returning for season 6.