The twosome sparked an instant connection in the season 4 pods, which aired on Netflix in March 2023. After days of deep conversation, Brett admitted that he was falling in love with the client lead recruiter without ever seeing her face. Tiffany, however, missed hearing Brett say those three words because she unintentionally fell asleep mid-conversation.
Brett was initially ready to give up on their love story, thinking that Tiffany had ghosted him after hearing his emotional confession. Instead, he stayed the course and proposed sight unseen.
By the time the pair’s May 2022 wedding day rolled around, they were each certain that one another would say “I do.”
“I felt like I really got to know Brett. I got to know him for who he is, and I was just like, ‘He would’ve shocked me if he said no,’” Tiffany exclusively told Us Weekly in March 2023. “But just being at the altar, I had no doubt in my mind that was, that was who I wanted to be with.”
Scroll below to see Tiffany and Brett’s complete relationship timeline: