Two of Dancing With the Stars' Season 14 competitors danced for the last time Monday night.
During Tuesday night's results show, hosts Tom Bergeron and Brooke Burke Charvet revealed America's votes--and were forced to send both Roshon Fegan and Melissa Gilbert home.
Though they made a massive comeback following their near-elimination last week (scoring an impressive 56/60 Monday) Fegan, 20, and his partner Chelsie Hightower failed to secure enough viewer votes to stay safe.
Birthday girl Gilbert--who turned 48 Tuesday--was also let go. (She and partner Maksim Chmerkovskiy came in dead last Monday, earning just 51/60 Monday.)
When a sympathetic Bergeron admitted he felt bad that the former Little House On the Prairie star would have to head home on her special day, a tearful Gilbert shook her head.
"I'm amazed I even made it this far," Gilbert shared of her DWTS journey. "[That] does make it a really incredible birthday."
Following Gilbert and Fegan's eliminations, four contestants move into the semifinals next Monday: Donald Driver, William Levy, Katherine Jenkins, and Maria Menounos.