Color us impressed! For the price of this product, the NYX HD Studio Photogenic Concealer performs as well as high-end alternatives. This lightweight, blendable formula provides medium coverage that doesn’t settle into creases. You can also use it as a contour. We gave this product a comedogenic rating of one out of five, since it has a small amount of just one comedogenic ingredient: coconut oil.

However, a few buyers complain that the bottle is quite small. This product may be drying, so be sure to apply moisturizer underneath it — especially if you have dry skin. As for toxicity, the formula gets a rating of three out of 10.

While it may be tempting to buy a concealer that contains salicylic acid or a similar anti-acne ingredient, you may be better off keeping your skincare separate from your makeup. We recommend using the acne treatment that works best with your skin, then applying a standard, non-comedogenic and low-toxicity concealer, like Flower Beauty’s Light Illusion. The reason? Other drugstore concealers advertised as being great for acne contain potentially irritating and comedogenic ingredients. We also like that this formula is full coverage, blendable and lightweight with a natural to radiant finish.

Unfortunately, color matching is not easy because this product comes in just 12 shades. Some buyers would have liked a bigger tube for the price. The formula is on the dryer side, so we recommend that you apply a moisturizer beneath it.

For dark circles, it helps to get a concealer that’s designed to cancel out purples and reds. The IT Cosmetics Under Eye Concealer is an excellent pick because it’s formulated for dark circles and provides full coverage. We like that a little goes a long way, and you can thin it out with a little moisturizer if you want a lighter feel. We gave this formula a comedogenic rating of one out of five.

As with most full-coverage formulas, this product may settle into fine lines and creases. A few buyers dislike the sticky consistency after application — we recommend blending it out very well and setting with a little powder. This product has a toxicity rating of three out of 10.

Struggling to even out some dark spots? Try the Revlon ColorStay Concealer, which offers buildable coverage that lightens and cancels out dark areas of the skin. Bonus: It contains caffeine, making it a great product to reduce puffy, dark circles as well. We gave this formula a comedogenic rating of one out of five.

Since the formula has a matte finish, it may be drying — apply moisturizer beneath it as needed. It may settle into fine lines and creases as a result. This product has a toxicity rating of three out of 10.

Combatting redness while still matching your skin tone is a tricky business, but the Catrice True Skin High Cover Concealer is up to the task. It provides full coverage and cancels out red and purple tones. It’s also lightweight and long-lasting — after a 12-hour day, it still looks great and has a low chance of settling into creases. We gave this product a comedogenic rating of 1/5.

Unfortunately, color matching may be difficult because the Catrice True Skin Concealer comes in just 14 shades. This product does not yet have a toxicity rating, though similar Catrice products have a rating between four and six out of 10.

Concealers tend to be drying, so finding a formula that is truly hydrating isn’t easy. We picked the NYX Bare With Me Hydrating Concealer because it contains glycerin and sunflower seed oil for a moisturizing boost. Plus, the medium coverage doesn’t settle into creases and blends well. We gave this product a 1/5 comedogenic rating. It also has a low toxicity rating of two out of 10.

Many buyers wish that NYX would change the pump on this product, which tends to be faulty. We also wish the shade range were a little more extensive. If you can’t find a good match, you may have a hard time getting the right coverage on dark circles and redness.

It’s hard to make dry, flaky and oily skin happy, but the Maybelline Fit Me Liquid Concealer could be just what your skin needs. The formula is oil-free, so it won’t clog pores or contribute to an oily feeling, and it contains glycerin to help moisturize and soothe skin. Buyers love that the formula provides medium coverage and never feels cakey or drying. We gave this product a comedogenic rating of two out of five.

Unfortunately, this product contains two parabens, which increase its toxicity and may lead to skin irritation. Some buyers also wish that the concealer provided a little more coverage. This formula has a toxicity rating of five out of 10.

If you’re looking for excellent coverage without the appearance of makeup, pick up a bottle of the Honest Beauty Fresh Flex Concealer. This product is EWG verified, meaning it doesn’t contain potentially irritating or toxic ingredients, and the clean formula contains hydrators like shea butter, hyaluronic acid, niacinamide and vitamin E to increase skin elasticity.

However, the product does contain alcohol which may be irritating on sensitive skin. Some buyers also note that it takes a long time to blend because it is liquidy. We wish the concealer came in more than 16 shades. As for its comedogenic rating, we gave this formula a two out of five because shea butter may clog pores.

Unfortunately, many medium to full-coverage concealers don’t work well on mature skin because they’re drying and settle into fine lines and creases. The Maybelline Instant Age Rewind Concealer sets itself above the rest because it is crease-resistant and ultra-hydrating without being thick or cakey. We give this product a comedogenic rating of one out of five.

While this product isn’t likely to clog pores, it is more likely than other products to cause irritation because it contains parabens. We also wish the sponge were pointed or not as big, because it makes it hard to apply product precisely. This product has a toxicity rating of three out of 10.

Looking for a formula that is both non-comedogenic and as clean as possible? Try the Maybelline Cover Stick Corrector. To apply, dot the face in the spots where you need coverage, then gently dab and blend. The results are impressive: The formula provides full coverage without caking. The EWG gave this product a one out of 10 toxicity rating, and we give this product a comedogenic rating of one out of five.

Unfortunately, the Maybelline Cover Stick has the least inclusive shade range of our recommendations with just six shades. It is also a little harder to apply than liquid concealers and may be too thick. If so, we recommend first warming up the tube in the palm of your hands to soften the product.

If you don’t have the time or patience to reapply concealer throughout the day, we recommend the L’Oréal Infallible Full Wear Waterproof Concealer. It applies beautifully in a thin layer and offers excellent coverage without feeling thick or cakey. Plus, it lasts all day long.

While this product does an excellent job of brightening dark circles and dark spots, it may be too illuminating for other areas of the face, like the cheeks or forehead. We’ve given this concealer a comedogenic rating of one out of five, but caution that it contains irritating ingredients, including seven fragrances and fragrance maskers, which may lead to breakouts