Who killed Sir William McCordle (Harry Potter’s Michael Gambon)? That’s what everyone at Gosford Park wants to know. William and his wife, Lady Sylvia (Kristin Scott Thomas), had invited more than a dozen people for a weekend at their lavish country estate, and almost all of them had a motive for offing the not-so-nice patriarch. Was it Constance, the Dowager Countess of Trentham (Maggie Smith), whose fancy title hides a dwindling bank account? Or did Henry Denton (Ryan Phillippe), a valet whose Scottish accent comes and goes, strike the killing blow?
On the surface, Gosford Park is a thrilling mystery — once the crime is committed, all the suspects are presented with a reasonable motive for committing murder. But look closer, and the 2001 film is much more than a mystery — it’s a biting satire about the conflicts between the upper and lower classes as they existed in Great Britain in the 1930s.
Director Robert Altman pokes fun at the rich for all their pointless rituals and material desires, as well as the poor servants for the same things. The ultimate joke of the film, and the key to solving the compelling mystery at its center, is that there’s not much that separates the two, and they have more in common than you think. The only downside to the film is that it ends — it’s so good, you want it to go on forever.