Lindsay Hubbard dug up the past — and spilled the tea — during the In the City premiere, claiming Danielle Olivera crossed a line with Linday’s ex-fiancé Carl Radke years prior.
“I’m certainly not going to make space in my life for someone who s***s on me any chance that they get,” Lindsay, 39, told the cameras during the Tuesday, May 19, episode of the new Bravo series, referring to her rocky friendship with Danielle, 37.
Lindsay claimed, “Every year it’s something” before offering to pull up her timeline and receipts of Danielle’s wrongdoings.
Lindsay then alleged that during season 4 of Summer House — which she starred on alongside Danielle for years before Danielle exited the show in 2024 ahead of season 9 — filmed in 2019 that after Lindsay and Carl, 41, tried to “date” Danielle made a move on him.
“[It] didn’t work out. He breaks up with me,” Lindsay said of that timeframe, claiming, “One week later, she’s giving him a hand job in the back of an Uber.”
Lindsay, who was engaged to Carl for a year before their August 2023 split, pointed out that Danielle also made their proposal all about her.
“That’s so f***ed up for everything that I’ve done to for that f***ing friendship,” Danielle told Kyle Cooke on Summer House in 2022 when she learned Carl was proposing and didn’t include her in any planning amid her and Lindsay’s highs and lows.
Lindsay asked the In the City producers to run the tapes, reminding fans of the OG series that Danielle called her a “f***ing monster” after she got engaged and then Lindsay threatened not to invite her to the nuptials.
Lindsay further reminded fans on Tuesday’s premiere that in 2024 when she was pregnant Danielle was “making off of these comments,” including questioning why she was OK with then-boyfriend Turner Kufe not living with her since they were about to have a baby together. (Lindsay gave birth to daughter Gemma in December 2024, and split with Kufe soon after her arrival.)
“Stop shitting on me!” Lindsay said about Danielle’s past actions before she was actually confronted with having to see her former BFF at a group gathering on In the City.
“I wanted to say, ‘Hi,’” Danielle said when she approached Lindsay, who was chatting with Kyle, 43, at the bar. “I was wondering if you would be open to lunch or a coffee? Whenever you’re free.”
Lindsay was visibly surprised by the invitation, responding, “Can I think about it? I’m a little busy these days”
“With a newborn? Yeah,” Danielle replied, after previously telling the cameras that she thought Lindsay had “ghosted our friendship” after Danielle met baby Gemma one year prior.
Kyle waited until Danielle walked away before telling Lindsay, “I don’t get it, if I can be honest.”
“There’s been so many things,” Lindsay explained of why she distanced herself from Danielle.
She then told Kyle about Danielle’s issues with her and Carl’s relationship.
“Carl and I got engaged, she had a freak out,” Lindsay recalled. “Before Carl and I got engaged, she gave him a hand job in the back of an Uber a week after we broke up. That’s f***ing weird.”
Fans of Summer House have seen Lindsay and Danielle’s best and worst moments as friends. Danielle joined the cast during season 2, which filmed in 2017. Before she came on the show she dated Carl.
Once the cameras were rolling the women became thick as thieves, later being dubbed the “Three Amigos” alongside Carl. However, when Lindsay and Carl started to date in summer 2019, it caused a small rift in Lindsay and Danielle’s friendship. (Carl and Danielle made out during the season 4 finale, but never fully got back together.)
After Carl and Lindsay split that summer, their friendship with Danielle got better again before they went off the rails in 2022 when the couple got engaged.
Danielle didn’t publicly congratulate the pair and when season 7 started to air in 2023, fans saw how upset Danielle was in real time about their relationship milestone.
When Carl called off his wedding to Lindsay in August 2023, Lindsay still went on her bachelorette party getaway and Danielle was by her side the whole time.
“People are like, ‘Do you talk to Carl?’ I’m like, ‘No, absolutely not,’” Danielle exclusively told Us Weekly in October 2023 of where allegiances lied. “There’s a line in the sand. I’m on Team Lindsay.”
Flash forward to September 2025, when In the City began filming, and Danielle and Lindsay were in another friendship rut.
“The last time I spoke to her was probably four months ago,” Danielle told the cameras on Tuesday’s episode. “That’s weird for us because we go back years and years. I’m just like, ‘What did I do?’”
In the City airs on Bravo Tuesdays at 9 p.m. ET.
