Biggest ‘Summer House’ Feuds Through the Years — And Where They Stand Now

Credit: Stephanie Diani/Bravo

Biggest ‘Summer House’ Feuds Through the Years — And Where They Stand Now

Bring on the heat. Every year, the cast of Summer House brings even more drama — and at least one new feud arises. The series focuses on several reality TV personalities as they live together for the summer in the Hamptons. The first season originally introduced viewers to Kyle Cooke, Lindsay Hubbard, Carl Radke, Everett Weston, Ashley Wirkus, Lauren Wirkus and more when it premiered in 2017. As the show gained popularity, new faces eventually joined the Hamptons family, including Amanda Batula, Daniella Olivera, Hannah Berner, Paige DeSorbo, Luke Gulbranson, Ciara Miller, Mya Allen and more. Over time, the reality show brought in various other Bravolebrities to guest star on the summer series. In the fifth season, the format changed to accommodate filming during the COVID-19 pandemic. The cast all lived and quarantined together for a full six weeks and during that time, a physical altercation broke out among the castmates, with crew members being forced to step in to intervene. [jwplayer fdhDr5Mt-zhNYySv2] “That was, I think, one of the most traumatic [things I have witnessed]. I know that’s being dramatic, but [there are] traumatic parts about being together,” Danielle told Us Weekly exclusively in February 2021. “Because we don’t leave each other, so much builds up and what is being said or — more so, what is not being said. It all kind of just bottles up and that bubble just really burst. I hated it. It was the worst thing to be around, but we had to deal with it.” Danielle later found herself in the middle of a tense feud with Ciara in the sixth season — and things got physical again. Their unexpected feud turned into one of the most shocking moments of the season when Ciara threw her wine glass at the entrepreneur during an Italian-themed dinner. “After the wine was thrown, she threw the wine glass and it shattered on my chest. I’m like, ‘What the f—k? Like, are you kidding me?’” Danielle exclusively told Us in December 2021. “And so, the truth is the next day, I saw bruises — like I had bruises — but Craig, who was there that weekend, he was, like, ‘Oh my God, I pulled you away that hard.’ … No, the bruises were because of that wine glass that she threw at me and shattered on my chest bone. I’m not OK. I’m not OK about it.” From lovers' quarrels to full-on brawls, here's a look back at some of the biggest Summer House feuds throughout the years:

Credit: Stephanie Augello/Shutterstock; Scott Roth/Invision/AP/Shutterstock

Lindsay vs Everett

In the first season of the reality show, the former couple were at each other's throats constantly with their relationship drama which stemmed from trust and commitment issues. The pair called it quits after a year together. Lindsay and her fiancé, Carl, are still friendly with Everett.

Credit: Gregory Pace/Shutterstock; Stephanie Diani/Bravo

Kyle vs the Entire Season 2 Cast

After filming the second season of the reality series, Kyle had a couple of things to get off his chest to his castmates. The Loverboy founder sent everyone who was in the Summer House that season a 17-page email airing his grievances over the treatment of his now-wife, Amanda. It's safe to say Kyle isn't in touch regularly with the Wirkus twins or Stephen McGee.

Credit: Stephen Lovekin/Shutterstock; Stephen Lovekin/Shutterstock

Lindsay vs Danielle

An argument between the two best friends went down in season 7 of the Bravo reality series, which will air in 2023, and led the two to have a falling out. While at BravoCon 2022, Lindsay told Us that “there was a lot of stuff [that] happened this summer” and she felt betrayed. Lindsay confirmed the costars are still in the middle of a complicated situation.

Credit: Stephanie Augello/Shutterstock; Stephen Lovekin/Shutterstock

Danielle vs Ciara

In season 6, the feud cemented itself as one of the most surprising fights when the nurse threw a glass of wine at Danielle after she defended Lindsay amid the publicist and Ciara’s love triangle with Southern Charm's Austen Kroll. After filming wrapped, Danielle told Us at BravoCon in October 2022 that the two women were able to smooth things over.

“Ciara and I, obviously, we got to know each other better and I literally stepped foot in the house, like, ‘I don't know how this is gonna go, but I'm open to it.’ And I think she was the same. And then Mya allowed us to become close,” she shared. “I became even closer with Mya, closer with Amanda, closer with Paige. It really opened up a lot of the friendships.”

Credit: Stephen Lovekin/Shutterstock; Scott Roth/Invision/AP/Shutterstock

Carl vs Lauren

The first two seasons of the reality show centered a lot on the relationship struggles between Carl and Lauren. The two’s showmance did not end well after Carl revealed he hooked up with other women. The two cut ties after the season 2 reunion when the Wirkus twins did not return for season 3.

Credit: Gregory Pace/Shutterstock; Evan Agostini/Invision/AP/Shutterstock; Stephanie Augello/Shutterstock

Kyle and Carl vs Luke

In the fifth season, the Summer House boys got into a brawl after a pub crawl-themed party. Kyle and Carl decided to call out Luke for his behavior toward women and the argument turned into an intense altercation. The trio worked things out after filming and are all friends now. Both Luke and Carl told Us in October 2022  that they regret this fight since the guys are all close now.

“I wish that I never would have almost come to blows with Carl and Kyle,” Luke shared. “I wish that never happened. But I will say that we as mature human beings had conversations, worked through it and honestly, it made us closer friends. I know that sounds weird, but that's really what happened."

Credit: Gregory Pace/Shutterstock; Gregory Pace/Shutterstock

Amanda vs Hannah

Besides the boy’s beef in season 5, Amanda and Hannah had their own drama going on. The pair’s friendship came to an end over Hannah’s issues with Kyle. The two are no longer friends and did not attend each other’s weddings.  

“At this point, I’m more sad about, like, where our relationship has gone vs her [Hannah] being there or not,” Amanda told Us in October 2021. “It’s our wedding day and we just want to be surrounded by, like, happiness and positivity. So, it’s not really going to make an impact. … I’m more upset about where things have gone and how they’ve gotten here.”

Credit: Image Press Agency/NurPhoto/Shutterstock; AFF-USA/Shutterstock

Lindsay vs Amanda

While appearing on Watch What Happens Live With Andy Cohen in October 2022, Amanda alleged that Lindsay was the “rudest” to fans. The Hubb House founder was not pleased with those comments and took to social media to share her displeasure. “Why would I do that if I didn’t like fans? Or if I was rude? Why would I VOLUNTEER to be at more events than I need to? Think about that one,” she wrote. The two have not worked it out quite yet.

Credit: Shutterstock(2)

Kyle vs Carl

The former Loverboy colleagues famously feuded over Carl's departure from Kyle's alcohol brand, with Carl exclusively telling Us in February 2023 why he decided to leave the company after getting sober in 2020.

“Going into the summer, I had my own feelings about where I was at with the business and my career trajectory. And at the end of the day, [thinking] ‘Is this the best thing for me?’ You know, I haven’t had a drink in, at that point, a year and a half, and working at an alcohol brand, it didn’t feel like it aligned authentically for me," he explained, noting it's "hard to watch" the drama unfold on season 7.

Kyle, for his part, understood where Carl was coming from in terms of his sobriety, but felt that he was "checked out" for a long time, he exclusively told Us that same month. The Maryland native said he paid Carl a "full-time salary for an entire year when he spent most of it checked out," and added that though his costar exited the company in "good graces," there were "plenty of opportunities to fire him."

Ultimately, the pair want to repair their bond. "I think now more than ever, we can focus on our friendship," Kyle told Us.