Born Caelynn Miller-Keyes in Fredericksburg, Virginia, the future Bachelor contestant won Miss Virginia Teen USA 2013. She continued to compete in beauty pageants, winning Miss North Carolina 2018 and finishing as the first runner-up for Miss USA.
The Virginia Commonwealth University alum competed for Colton Underwood’s affections on season 23 of The Bachelor. After making it to the final four, she was eliminated and appeared on season 6 of Bachelor in Paradise. During the 2019 season, Miller-Keyes’ pre-show hookup with Blake Horstmann became a story line before she settled down with Dean Unglert. While Unglert broke up with Miller-Keyes on her birthday, he returned to the beach and they left Mexico together.
Miller-Keyes and Unglert have been going strong ever since, explaining in June 2020 that they wear rings to show their commitment to each other even though they aren’t engaged or married. They reside outside of Las Vegas.