Credit: Jamie McCarthy/; Jeffrey Mayer/

It appears that Jennifer Aniston isn't the only celebrity who's stuck in a bit of a red carpet style rut.

Katie Holmes wore a simple, dark V-neck dress from her own Holmes & Yang collection with nude heels to the premiere of her new movie, Don't Be Afraid of the Dark in New York City on Monday night.

While she looked chic, the dress was nearly identical to the one that she wore to the LA Film Festival in June., which she also paired with tan heels and the same gold Jennifer Meyer pendant necklace (it has a "S" for Suri).

In all fairness, the A-lister recently stepped way out of her fashion comfort zone on the August cover of Vogue Espana. The 32-year-old showed off her kinky side in a skintight black lace Lanvin dress and a leather dominatrix cap. The normally subdued star vamped it up for the camera with a sexy stare and pout.

Tell Us: Do you think Katie needs to switch up her look?